Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt Recipe

This Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt recipe might just be my new addiction.  I was sitting here thinking, Hmmm I wonder if Nutella and coffee would be good together…  Allow we to answer that with a big HELL YES.  When I decided to whip up this concoction I new it would probably be insanely good or an epic fail.  I am pleased to say that it turned out to be scrumptious.  If you like these ingredients on their own, you will probably love them combined.

Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt Recipe

nutella coffee frozen yogurt

Here’s what I used:

  • 1 Cup Fage Greek Yogurt
  • 3/4 Cup Skim Milk
  • 3/4 Cup of hot water (to dilute instant coffee)
  • 1 Heaping TBS Instant Coffee (I originally used 2 TBS and it was a little too strong)
  • 1/4 Cup Nutella
  • 1/4 Tsp Sea Salt

nutella coffee ingredients

Stir all of those ingredients into a bowl and chill for at least 20 minutes.  I did not chill mine because I am inpatient.  It definitely could have been firmer.

nutella coffee mixture

The mixture looks quite gross, but believe me it won’t be when it’s done.  After you chill the mixture, pour it into your ice cream maker and follow its directions.

nutella coffee frozen yogurt

Enjoy!  Try not to eat the entire 2 quarts in one sitting!

Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt Recipe
Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt. If you like coffee and Nutella, you will most likely love them together!
Serves: 4 - 6
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
  • 1 Cup Fage Greek Yogurt
  • ¾ Cup Skim Milk
  • A little less than ½ Cup Organic Mascobado Cane Sugar
  • ¾ Cup of hot water (to dilute instant coffee)
  • 1 Heaping TBS Instant Coffee (I originally used 2 TBS and it was a little too strong)
  • ¼ Cup Nutella
  • ¼ Tsp Sea Salt
  1. Mix all above ingredients
  2. Chill for at least 20 minutes
  3. Pour chilled mixture into ice cream maker
  4. Follow the directions of your ice cream maker

About Jennifer

Jennifer is the owner/editor of Sweep Tight. She is married to a wonderful man and together they live with their two dogs. Jen loves to review products, host giveaways, enter sweepstakes, go boating, play word games, and is completely in love with all forms of social media. Other hobbies include reading, yoga and running. Connect with Jennifer on Google +


  1. Sarah K. (The Mama Pirate) says:

    Yum! I adore anything with Nutella. Now that summer if here I have got to find our ice cream maker and dust it off, thanks for sharing this!

  2. Got all the way to the bottom, was super excited. Don’t have an ice cream maker. Bummer.

  3. This looks delicious. I don’t think I’ve ever had coffee yogurt before but I have had coffee ice cream. Thank you for sharing this great recipe!!


  1. [...] vanilla and caramel notes! This sugar is amazing in/on everything from baked goods, to oatmeal, to frozen yogurt, to your tea and coffee! *interesting fact: Did you know that SOME sugars are actually good for [...]

  2. [...] 2. Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt Recipe [...]

  3. [...] decided to have fun with my Cuisinart ice cream maker once again.  Since I struck gold with my Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt recipe, I thought I would give it another whirl.  I had heard that people have used cottage cheese [...]

  4. [...] you can probably tell I have a bit of a Nutella obsession.  I can easily eat it with a spoon, but prefer to experiment with recipes.  I also like to use [...]

  5. […] Nutella Coffee Frozen Yogurt from Sweep Tight […]

  6. […] personal favorite recipe that I make all of the time is my Nutella Coffee Froze Yogurt. I cannot wait to try out more of these fabulous recipes.  These recipes have inspired me to get […]

Copyright © 2014 Sweep Tight - All Rights Reserved - Web Service by RL Web Designs. Hosted by WiredTree.