Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

Nutella is one of my most favorite guilty pleasures. Aside from just eating it with a spoon from the jar, I like to try various recipes using it. Most of you have probably caught on to my frozen treat obsession, so I was on a mission to find another one to make easily. Post contains affiliate links.

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

First I tried just mixing Cool Whip and Nutella. That is tasty, but it doesn’t freeze. I was trying to be crafty and freeze little heart-shaped bites, but it was like a gummy mess. #fail Then, I came across a post where they created Nutella Cool Whip popsicles. Turns out you need the milk in there to make it freeze. Hey, I am slowly learning.

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

  • 1 Cup Cool Whip
  • 1/2 Cup Milk
  • 3 Tbs Nutella

Back to the kitchen where I tried to use my Zoku Quick Pop maker with this mixture. Another #fail as it was too soft and just stuck to the sides.

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

Okay, let’s try these handy push up pops that I just had to have (and only used once). Yes – big #win! They turned out to be just scrumptious. The mixture doesn’t freeze completely solid, so they are easy to push up and bite without hurting your teeth. The consistency is perfect and the flavor just delicious.

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

The taste reminds me a little like a Frosty from Wendy’s. Of course when I told Shelley this she then rattled off several cute names to call this creation: Frosticle Push Up, Frosticle Fudgsicle, Frosty NutUps, NutellUps… whatever you want to call them they are quick, easy and make for a yummy frozen treat!

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe

Nutella Frozen Push Ups Recipe


  • 1 Cup Cool Whip
  • 1/2 Cup Milk - I used 2%
  • 3 Tablespoons Nutella


  1. Mix all very well.
  2. Pour mixture into a push up container or popsicle mold. An ice cube tray would work, too.
  3. Freeze.

The Nutella flavor is not very strong. Mike is not a Nutella fan {gasp} and he liked the flavor of these push ups.  Also, you could just as easily freeze these in a popsicle mold or however you would like, but they are super fun in push up form. I purchased my push up containers from amazon.

 Find It Here Find It Here Find It Here

Are you a fan of Nutella? Do you think you would like these Nutella frozen push up treats?

About Jennifer

Jennifer is the owner of Sweep Tight. She is married to a wonderful man and together they live with their three dogs. When Jen isn't working on her blog, you can find her reading, playing word games, running, doing yoga, or boating on Lake Michigan. Jen is completely in love with all forms of social media. Connect with Jennifer on Google +


  1. These look really good! Where did you find the push up pops?

  2. candy kratzer wenzel says:

    Simple recipe thanks. Will have to use ice trays.

  3. I have to be honest, I have never eaten Nutella, but I have heard great things about it. From what I hear Nutella is absolutely delicious, so based on that I would definitely try it and I have no doubt that I would love these pushup treats. Thank you for sharing this recipe.

  4. These look absolutely amazing! Thanks for sharing!!!

  5. I so need to make this for my kids, they love Nutella!

  6. I love push pops and this looks amazing! You seriously can’t go wrong with Nutella.

  7. Those push pops look absolutely amazing! I need to get some Nutella stat!

  8. PS – I LOVE your new site design!

  9. I grew up on Nutella in the late 70’s when we were stationed in West Germany. So glad to see the craze finally hit the U.S.!

  10. Dominique says:

    I’m not a huge Nutella fan, but perhaps frozen, it’s something the kids would really enjoy! Thanks!

  11. LOVE this.. I’m such a nutella addict and grew up with it in Germany and still eat it all the time, it’s MY comfort food when I’m homesick I buy a jar and eat it.. call me crazy.. But it’s me 🙂 great recipe.. will have to try it

  12. My sons LOVE Nutella so I am going to make this for them for Valentine’s Day!! Thank you for doing the trial and error so I can get it right the first time 🙂 lol

  13. My kids LOVE nutella so I will make these as a treat for them on Valentines day!

  14. 3 ingredients, that’s it? Oh my goodness, push-ups remind me of my childhood and when paired with Nutella…oh my yum!

  15. I like your persistence in finding just the right recipe. Right now it’s snowing and I don’t feel like having one but when the weather gets warmer these will be great.

  16. It’s still too cold here for me to think of making these: current wind chill 16 degrees (better than minus numbers)

  17. It’s supposed to be warm tomorrow and this would be yummy.

  18. These sound delicious. I love Nutella. I’ll be making these!

  19. Yum! I love Nutella and these would be perfect for when the weather finally warms up. Thanks for sharing your kitchen experiment!

  20. Shannon says:

    OMG I love Nutella so I am sure I will love these! Thank you for sharing with us!!!!!


  1. […] Nutella Frozen Push Ups from Sweep Tight […]

  2. […] Nutella Frozen Push Ups – Sweep Tight […]

  3. […] 3 Ingredient Frozen Push Ups from Sweep Tight  {pictured above} […]

Copyright © 2014 Sweep Tight - All Rights Reserved - Web Service by RL Web Designs. Hosted by WiredTree.